Memo from Philosophy Defense Force
Re: The Non-Identity Problem
March 21, 2025
Dear Mr. Muskrat:
We at the Philosophy Defense Force are glad to have learned of your budding interest in population ethics. Simultaneously, we are concerned by your use of the works of Derek Parfit in your recent column entitled “Non-Identity: Why it is permissible for me to destroy the Amazon rainforest to build a Hypertruck racetrack”. Your argument contends that:
A totally real organization founded by Adam…
In Reasons and Persons, Derek Parfit observed…
- [P1]The “Person-Affecting Claim”: An act A is wrong only if there is some existing or future person whom A affects for the worse.
- [P2]If you destroy the Amazon rainforest, all present people will be affected for the better due to the sheer joy of watching Hypertrucks at their breathtaking top speed of 45 miles per hour.
- [P3]If you destroy the Amazon rainforest, all future persons who will exist will not be identical to any future person who would have existed had you not done so, and they will live lives that are well worth living—though they will carry the burden of climate change.
- [P4]The “Non-Identity Point”: An act A which creates a new person P does not affect P for the worse if the following two conditions are satisfied:
(1) P has a life that is worth living; and
(2) Had A not been performed, P would never have existed. - [C1]Therefore, nobody will be affected for the worse if you destroy the Amazon rainforest.
- [C2]Therefore, it is not wrong for you to destroy the Amazon rainforest.1
It may be that your argument was entirely flawless at the time when you published it. But, in our effort to rationally persuade you not to destroy the Amazon rainforest, we must now use extra-rational means.
We have selected a sperm and egg cell from two consenting donors now, in the year 2025. These gametes are already in cryo-storage on a satellite which will return to Earth in the year 2100. In that year, an automatic incubator will thaw and fertilize those gametes and carry the resulting child to term. The child will be born in the world that exists in 2100, whatever it is like. This child will exist, whatever you do. And its life will be affected for the worse if you destroy the Amazon than if you do not.
You are hereby forewarned that your action may now be morally impermissible, by the lights of your own argument.
Yours sincerely,
The Philosophy Defense Force
Attn: Patrick H. Pan
Northern California Field Office
Philosophy Hall, University of California, Berkeley
Notes
- I owe the formulation of P1 and P4 to Johann Frick’s Phil 2 lectures; see Parfit, Reasons and Persons, ch. 16 for the original statement of the problem.
Questions, objections, or a better example? Write to me: patrick.pan@patrickpan.com.